www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,8128-1008434,00.html
The Times
February 20, 2004

Critics of GM crops furious at ministers' approval

By Nigel Hawkes

OPPONENTS of genetically modified crops reacted with fury yesterday to leaked 
Cabinet minutes indicating that ministers have decided to approve their 
cultivation.

An announcement on the commercial planting of GM maize could come as early as 
next week.

Michael Meacher, the former Environment Minister, said that there was no 
“moral, scientific or political authority” for the move and green campaigners 
said the leaked minutes showed that big business had triumphed over public 
opinion.

The minutes show Margaret Beckett, the Secretary of State for Environment, 
Food and Rural Affairs, arguing that there was “no scientific case for an 
outright ban on cultivation of GM crops”. The public, she said, wanted “more 
information and a strong regulatory regime”, not a ban.

She said that GM crops should be considered on a case-by-case basis. In 
discussion, the minutes record, the point was made that while a ban “was the 
easy way out, it was an irrational way for the Government to proceed, 
particularly given the symbolic importance of the decision for the 
Government’s science policy and the UK science base”.

Mr Meacher was unconvinced. “Why is the Government going ahead?” he asked. “It 
is not because of the science, it is because of the Bush Administration 
applying pressure and because of big companies like Monsanto who want to make 
a big profit out of cornering the world food supply. It has nothing to do 
with feeding the world.”

Ben Ayliffe, of Greenpeace, said: “Going ahead with GM would be a disaster for 
farming and the countryside. There are no rules in place to stop GM 
contaminating organic and non-GM crops.”

Tony Juniper, of Friends of the Earth, said: “The views of the British public 
count for nothing when it comes to looking after the interests of Tony 
Blair’s business friends.”

The Royal Society welcomed the move. A spokesman said: “The results of the 
farm-scale trials, which were published in a Royal Society journal last 
October, show that the weed management of the GM maize variety clearly had a 
less damaging effect on farmland wildlife than current conventional 
practice.”

DEBATE
Is the Government right to sanction GM crops?

Send your e-mails to debate@thetimes.co.uk